Artefact # 2: MDDE 611: Foundations of Adult Education

My second artefact is from MDDE 611 International Issues in Distance Education. Reflection begins how I developed as a learner and extends to how this artefact enables me to critically think, and accept criticisms. 

Artefact #2

Artefact # 2: MDDE 611 Foundations of Adult Education

Course Summary:

MDDE 611 was one of the first courses I took within the Master of Education in Distance Education program. The primary aims of this course are to introduce you to the foundations and purposes of adult education, and to provide you with an overview of adult education theory and practice. This course acts as a foundation for studying other adult education courses and related fields.

My Artefact Summary

This assignment had us critique a historical or contemporary adult education program.  In our critique we were to integrate the historical, philosophical and socio-economical foundations of adult education into a review of a program. The program I chose was one that I had been actively involved with; The Girl Guides of Canada. Adult members are required to take countless trainings, and courses to ensure they are capable, and have the necessary skills to lead adventures with school aged children. These trainings are a component of the Girl Guides of Canada program, thus I considered them a contemporary adult education program. 

Reflection

As I reflect upon this assignment I remember how long it took me to recognize adult education programs can be found almost everywhere. However, I believe it is where my passion of adult education programs stemmed. I am constantly trying to improve adult education programs, particularly trainings. I have seen on many occasions how administrative decisions, fears and beliefs can curb even the most excellent programs (6.2).

One of the first challenges I encountered was prior to beginning this assignment. Like, many students I didn`t know what topic to cover – I wasn`t sure what would be a good adult education program to cover. While sitting in a Girl Guides training about new regulations in completing paper work I realized that adult education programs need not be formal learning centres. Adult education programs exist not only at post-secondary institutions but also within our communities, churches and hobbies! At the time most Girl Guide trainings were done within a classroom setting, they were done during evenings and weekends. Dedicated volunteers would travel miles, pay out of pocket for travel expenses and sit through day long trainings that could have easily been delivered through online courses (1.1)

To prepare myself for this assignment I logged into the learning platform of the Girl Guide training program and reviewed many of the online reviews (from volunteer leaders) and reviewed the courses that were being offered, their location, and time (1.5). What I quickly noted in my preliminary research was that several of these courses and trainings could be delivered through an online system, the platform they had to record trainings could also be used to deliver training packets (1.7). Many of the trainings that reviewed protocols, paperwork, theories and practical pedagogy could be learnt online – likely less expensive as well. I firmly believe 70% of the Girl Guide trainings could be delivered through an online platform, the remaining 30% would need to remain in the existing format (1.8).

This assignment was to be presented to a group, I had to ensure my audience could grasp the culture of the Girl Guides of Canada while remaining unbiased to my proposed solutions (1.9). I knew the platform existed, it simply had to be expanded, tests could be completed to ensure competencies were met, and trainings could be tracked. My audience had a Distance Education background, they knew the same theories as I, what needed to be done was develop a concise presentation that allowed them to see how this organization could be augmented with a great training program (5.6). My audience saw the benefits of online training modules and suggested all trainings be presented online, with the incorporation of virtual learning. I felt confident defending my ideas and solutions because I knew how beneficial some in person trainings could be; especially when in practice (4.3). 

Creating an online training module would save valuable resources within this organization. Volunteers would no longer be bound by time, space and resources. The advantages to this would be volunteer leaders could take online trainings when it was convenient to them, they could study at home, and keep the resources they acquire through the course (6.4). The disadvantages to online training are that some material needs to be learnt in its original setting (3.4).

Today, I work closely with the California school systems. On more than one occasion I have been introduced to classrooms that have iPads for a classroom, but don`t use them as they don`t have the necessarily training to incorporate technology into their classroom. When I ask educators why they are hesitating their answers are often the same: they don’t have the time to familiarize themselves with the product, they don`t have the time to attend the trainings (1.3). These trainings occur on weekends in a classroom setting away from their hometown. As these iPads sit on the shelves not being used it is the student experience that suffers (2.4).  There are many innovative tools for educators to use within their classrooms, but this technology is not being used as teachers lack the confidence and trainings necessary. If educators could receive coherent, simple online trainings more would be inclined to take them on their own time (3.5).

As I re-read this artefact I wish I had taken a closer examination of the role of socio-economics in this case. While many volunteer leaders take mandatory trainings to enhance their unit`s experience, some view these trainings as an opportunity to network, socialize and gather new ideas (2.1).

Application

As I proceed within my career in the education sector I refer back to this assignment as a reminder that difference demographics have different ideologies. It`s important to understand all underlying motives when considering the delivery of trainings, networking is a positive outcome to classroom trainings. Giving people the option is perhaps the best way to ensure all students (young and old) are receiving the experience that suits their needs. The needs of the student, educator, organization and business need to be meet.

Comments

Rita Zuba Prokopetz
25 November 2016, 5:59 PM

Hi Natasha, 

I read with interest your descriptive paragraphs under both Course summary and Artefact summary. I realized that the information was mostly about the “product” you chose to present to your readers rather than the “process” you underwent in the selection of the assignment, the application of what you learned and the impact of this new learning on you both personally and professionally. 

For example, the following statement is a step-by-step narrative of “what happened” – “To prepare myself for this assignment I logged into the learning platform of the Girl Guide training program and reviewed many of the online reviews (from volunteer leaders) and reviewed the courses that were being offered, their location, and time (1.5).” 

You proceed by mentioning how “your audience” felt regarding some of the points you made. I wonder if you could think about “how you” felt instead, and how that perception impacted your subsequent choices / thought process in MDDE 611. 

Thanks, Natasha! I look forward to viewing this page again once your have considered some of the changes suggested.

Rita Zuba Prokopetz
30 November 2016, 6:22 PM

Hi Natasha,

Just a reminder that the list of competencies (MDDE Learning Competencies) is not required, ok?

Thanks!

Arlo
01 December 2016, 12:58 PM

Hi, Natasha:

I'll offer comments on an artefact-by-artefact basis as I go through items 2 through 5, and the conclusion.  (I'll avoid comments on the introduction and 1st artefact since to get to this point you've already received a "pass" on those two)

My first reaction is that when considering seemingly different situations, the similarities are often greater than the differences.  I could take what you've written above, replace "Girl Guides of Canada" with "Air Cadet League of Canada", put my name at the bottom and have something that pretty closely reflects the situation in that other organisation.  Like you, I find that "Adult education programs exist not only at post-secondary institutions but also within our communities, churches and hobbies!"  Our backgrounds with education will certainly help us in our other activities -- marketing for you, management and aviation for me.  

I like the layout of your material and the way it flows.  It's easy to read and the material flows logically.

In the "nit-picky department":

  1. In the third sentence of "My Artefact Summary" contains a semi-colon rather than a colon: "The program I chose was one that I had been actively involved with; The Girl Guides of Canada."
  2. The first sentence of the "Application" section ends with "...a  reminder that difference demographics have different ideologies."
  3. I'm with you when it comes to the advantages of distance learning in contexts such as the Guides.  Given those advantages, I'm curious about why the organisation mostly (or completely) uses other approaches.  Perhaps the powers that be don't know there's a different way???  Perhaps they've tried distance learning and it didn't work???  Perhaps they have no one to lead the charge??? Regardless of what the reason is, it would seem interesting to discover what the reason is ... they may have a good point -- although the distance educator part of me assumes otherwise.
  4. Two things that caught my attention while reading your text was your use of "trainings" and "learnt".  Technically, each can be argued to be acceptable, but they each struck me as examples of different wording and each caused me to pause in my reading of your material as my mind headed briefly down an "Is that correct?" distraction.  Not a "plus", not a "minus" ... perhaps not even "interesting"; but for what it's worth...
  5. I know I said I wouldn't comment on the pages that have been graded already, but ... in your Introduction under "About Natasha", we find the sentence, "I was presented with the opportunity to aid the in the expansion of our organization".

This page was an interesting read, Natasha.  I look forward to checking out the following pages.

Take whatever comments make sense and seem useful -- blast anything that seems out to lunch or off the mark.  Just chalk the latter group up to the ramblings of a course mate who's still suffering from completing his e-portfolio this week.

Cheers,

Arlo

3 comments